Essay II

When Nations Lose Their Story, Regions Rise

Why Regional Identity Re-Emerges When the Monoculture Fails

If you want to understand what comes next in America, you must begin with a simple truth:

People cannot live without a story. Not as individuals. Not as families. And certainly not as nations.

A story is not decoration. It is orientation.

It tells people who they are, what matters, what is expected of them, and what kind of future they are moving toward. When a story is alive, people endure hardship willingly. When it dies, even comfort becomes unbearable.

When the story dies, the culture dies.
When the culture dies, the people scatter.
And when the people scatter, they instinctively reach for something smaller, truer, and older—something they can actually hold.

That is why the future does not belong to abstractions. It belongs to regions.

This essay explains why.

I. The National Story Has Collapsed

You can feel it everywhere.

In conversations that go nowhere.
In politics that rage without resolution.
In institutions that still function but no longer inspire.
In families and communities that feel increasingly unmoored.

These are not isolated failures. They are symptoms of a deeper collapse:

America no longer shares a national myth.

Not a slogan. Not a brand. Not a holiday performance.

A myth—the shared story that once told Americans who they were, what they owed one another, and why the whole project mattered.

If you doubt this, ask yourself a simple question:

What is America’s shared national story today?

If an answer comes to mind, ask the second question:

Do you believe 350 million Americans actually believe it?

The answer is obvious.

Without a shared myth, a nation does not become enlightened or pluralistic. It becomes a crowd—loud, anxious, fragmented, and perpetually searching for meaning it cannot articulate.

The monoculture that replaced the older American story promised unity and delivered isolation. It promised equality and delivered loneliness. It promised progress and delivered exhaustion. It has no land, no memory, no hardship, and no inherited expectations—and therefore no authority.

A new national myth cannot simply be declared from the center. The center is hollow.

So when the national story collapses, something else happens.

II. When National Identity Fails, People Don’t Disappear — They Localize

This pattern is ancient.

When empires fracture…
When central authority loses legitimacy…
When shared stories evaporate…

People do not dissolve into isolated individuals.

They fall back into the smallest unit capable of sustaining meaning:

the region.

This is not regression. It is re-rooting.

The nation becomes too abstract.
The city too artificial.
The family alone too fragile.

But the region—the land itself—still has the power to form people.

It shapes habits and temperament.
It shapes expectations and cooperation.
It shapes what virtues are required and what vices are punished.

Where land still matters, culture can still exist.

And where culture exists, story can return.

III. Why the Region Is the Only Scale Where Culture Can Be Rebuilt

A region gives people something the monoculture never can:

It touches them.
It shapes them.
It forms them.

Weather forms people.
Altitude forms people.
Distance forms people.
Soil and water form people.
Silence forms people.
Constraint forms people.

And the same conditions that shape one person shape everyone else around them.

That is what creates a people—not shared opinions, but shared conditions.

1. Regions Give Belonging, Not Slogans

Belonging does not come from ideology. It comes from shared realities:

Winters that must be prepared for.
Storms that isolate communities.
Droughts, floods, and fire seasons.
Mountain passes, river crossings, long distances.

Regional belonging is physical, not conceptual. Lived, not performed.

2. Regions Restore Cultural Memory

People remember who they are when they remember:

The winter that stranded half the county.
The year the river flooded.
The fire that changed the valley.
The way grandparents read the weather.
The sound of boots on snow.
The first warm week in March that fools everyone.

These memories are not political. They are inherited.

Regional memory is the antidote to cultural amnesia.

3. Regions Strengthen Family Continuity

Identity is not passed down by national institutions.

It is passed down through: seasonal rhythms, inherited skills, shared labor, local rituals, and the unspoken knowledge of “this is how our people live here.”

A family that knows its region knows itself.

4. Regions Bind People Through Cooperation

Hard places demand humility.

You pull strangers out of ditches during blizzards.
You shovel together.
You mend fences together.
You sandbag together.
You check on neighbors because the night is too cold to gamble with.

This is not ideology. It is formation.

5. Regions Generate Living Myths

Where formation exists, stories accumulate.

Heroes emerge.
Archetypes take shape.
Virtues become visible.
Expectations solidify.

From this, a myth emerges—not fantasy, but meaning.

And when the monoculture arrives with its weightless slogans, the response is immediate and visceral:

This is fake.
This has no roots here.
This is not how we live.

That is why regional myth has power. And monoculture does not.

IV. Why Some Regions Are Better Positioned Than Others

Not every region is equally prepared for renewal.

Some lack hardship.
Some lack continuity.
Some lack memory.
Some have been fully absorbed into the monoculture.

The regions most likely to lead what comes next share common traits:

Where these conditions remain, identity can be rebuilt.

V. A Region of Maximum Formation

There is a broad interior region of the American West where these conditions still hold with unusual density.

It is defined less by borders than by elevation, climate, and distance. By mountains rather than metros. By constraint rather than convenience.

Most importantly, it is still a frontier—not metaphorically, but materially.

The frontier is not empty land. It is untamed conditions.

Altitude. Weather. Isolation. Risk. Scarcity.

In American history, renewal has always emerged from frontiers—not because they are romantic, but because they still form people.

This region retains a lineage of archetypes that once defined the American story and never fully disappeared here:

The Cowboy, steward of land and liberty.
The Soldier, bearer of duty, sacrifice, and continuity.
The Rancher, whose memory is measured in seasons, not quarters.
The Miner and Builder, carving civilization from stone and snow.
The Engineer and Scientist, solving the impossible under constraint.
The Guide, whose wisdom is learned, not taught.
And the Founder—the modern frontier builder, creating not out of abundance but necessity, innovating not for status but survival.

These figures share a moral inheritance the monoculture no longer understands: responsibility, stewardship, sacrifice, and duty to something beyond the self.

Here, an older moral architecture still lingers—not as doctrine, but as habit. An echo of Christianity remains embedded in how work, land, neighbor, and obligation are understood.

This is why formation still happens here without permission, without bureaucracy, and without ideology.

Not because anyone invented a myth.

But because the land never stopped telling one.

Print this essay